17 The
agency notes that it seems likely that the respondents in both
of the surveys cited overstated the frequency with which they
check tire pressure, particularly given the fact that these
surveys were conducted during the height of publicity about
tire failures on sport utility vehicles in the late 2000 and
early 2001.
18 For
purposes of this discussion, the agency classified pick-up
trucks, SUVs, and vans with either P-metric, LT, or flotation
tires as light trucks.
19 In
response to the TREAD Act, NHTSA has added new tire related
variables and attributes, including tire make, model,
recommended tire pressure, actual tire pressure, and tread
depth to its crash databases. These new variables will provide
more specific tire data for vehicles involved in
crashes.
20 These
crash databases are the NASS-CDS and the Fatality Analysis
Reporting System (FARS).
21
Goodyear submitted these data to the docket in a letter dated
September 14, 2001. See Docket No. NHTSA-2000-8572-160. OMB
criticized NHTSA's application of these data to certain vehicle
types in estimating safety benefits for this rulemaking. The
agency responds to that criticism below in section VI.F.,
"Technical Foundation for NHTSA's Safety Benefit Analyses." The
Alliance also questioned NHTSA's use of the Goodyear data. The
agency explains its use of the Goodyear data below in footnotes
22 and 23, and in the agency's Final Economic Analysis
(FEA).
22 For
example, the VRTC only tested new tires, not worn tires that
are more typical of the tires on most vehicles. In addition,
the NHTSA track surface is considered to be aggressive in that
it allows for maximum friction with tire surfaces. It is more
representative of a new road surface than the worn surfaces
experienced by the vast majority of road traffic. The previous
Goodyear tests on wet surfaces were conducted on surfaces with
.05 inch of standing water. This is more than would typically
be encountered under normal wet road driving conditions. The
agency expressed concerns with the adequacy of both sets of
test data in a memo to the docket. (Docket No.
NHTSA-2000-8572-81.)
23 For
example, in its more recent tests Goodyear tested tires with
two tread depths: full tread, which is representative of new
tires, and half tread, which is representative of worn tires.
Goodyear also conducted wet surface tests on surfaces with .02
inch of standing water, which is more representative of typical
wet road driving conditions.
24
Docket No. NHTSA-2000-8572-26.
25 The
Aerospace Corporation, Evaluation of Techniques for Reducing
In-use Automotive Fuel Consumption, June 1978.
26
Docket No. NHTSA-2000-8572-26.
Full Report from the National Highway
Traffic Administration (NHTSA), Department of
Transportation
(DOT)
Do you have any comments about this article? If you do,
please write to: , we would love to hear from you.
Still yet to find the information or the answer you need?
Our site contains many useful automotive related articles that
will be helpful to you, enjoy.
|